Girls wear pink, boys wear blue. Girls play with dolls, boys play with Hot Wheels. From birth we have the differences between boys and girls drilled into our heads over and over and made to believe that there is a defined line between man and woman, girl and boy, feminine and masculine. Generally people associate with one or the other without a moment of questioning anything else, whether or not the gender they identify is the same as the sex they were assigned at birth.
I am Gender fluid. This does not apply to me.
Unless one happens to be personally involved in the LGBT community, gender variance is not something most will ever learn about in a meaningful way. Breaking the binary of man and woman comes as a shock to the average person, and when someone I know encounters gender variance I always hear about it. The retelling of the story usually has a tone similar to as though the person encountered an individual with a tattoo on their forehead. Needless to say, not following the binary can be difficult for anyone to understand.
What is “gender fluid” anyway? Well, to know gender fluidity it helps to know similar terms to avoid confusion.
Gender fluid/Gender queer: when a person’s gender identity shifts and flows between man, woman, neither, both, or something in-between.
Androgynous: This is the “in-between” identity. Androgynous individuals generally identify as being neither man nor woman, but rather something in-between.
Bi-gendered: This is the “both” identity. These people feel as though their gender is not either, but rather a combination of both man and woman.
Long story short: my gender identity shifts and changes and I don’t always feel either man or woman. With a constant and rapid changing of such a vital aspect of my identity, my gender fluidity is a very large part of my life.
I am female assigned at birth and most often identify as androgynous or masculine, so to make sure I am never too far out of my comfort zone, I try to dress in a manner without obvious gender leanings. My hair is cut very short without being “butch”, but I always have my eyeliner handy to I can doll up at a moment’s notice. Thankfully, I was also blessed with a naturally androgynous appearance so should I decide to express myself as distinctly male or female, I can pull it off without too much difficulty.
My appearance is not the only thing that shifts along with my identity. My demeanor and attitude can also change drastically.
My Significant Other has a surprising ability to keep up with my shifting gender and has absolutely no difficulty adapting to my behaviour. He is straight, so when I have more masculine leanings we go what I refer to as “Bro Mode”. When in Bro Mode he treats me exactly like any of our other guy friends. We rough house, kick ass at video games, check out girls, typical guy stuff.
My significant other owns a Fiero, which is an American-made sports car made only for a few years in the mid-to-late ’80s. He needed to get a part for the car and I went with him on a road trip to a town about an hour away to get it. On the way we were blasting tunes from the radio and talking cars. I believe the discussion was regarding my liking for modern Dodge Chargers over Challengers, Mustangs, and Camaros because of the Charger’s ability to gracefully evolve to fit the times as oppose to the other cars which seemed to directly copy/paste their features after their older generations on to modern body types (but this is just my opinion). Suddenly a love song came on the radio. Immediately we were met with an awkward hush in the conversation. Just the two of us, two bros, sitting together and listening to a love song on the radio.
This is the same guy I cuddle with every night and the same guy I bake brownies for when he’s having a bad day.
There are days when I feel more feminine and I’ll break out my adorable red and black plaid skirt, listen to Nicki Minaj, and just get bored to death of pwning noobs at Halo or Call of Duty.
These shifts can be extremely rapid or be months apart, and generally I don’t even notice them myself until I am hit with an anxiety attack over my appearance. If I have been feeling masculine and suddenly shift to being feminine, I look at myself and become upset because I’m not pretty. The worse feelings come from being masculine when I’m stuck in a woman’s body. My breasts are like a huge neon sign screaming “GIRL” when I want to be read as Man. My body is not nearly as versatile as my identity and this fact causes quite a lot of personal strain. The constant shifting is confusing and has brought me a lot of doubts. For years I suspected I was transgendered because of how deeply the pain of being physically female caused me when I felt like a man on the inside. I realized that I was incorrect. A person realizes pain more so than when there isn’t pain to be felt. In the times I was identifying as female, I didn’t notice that my identity had merely shifted and not that “being a woman wasn’t so bad right now”. Being genderfluid can be agonizing and terrible thing.
But being gender fluid can also be a liberating, fun, and amazing thing. I get a personal thrill when I’m feeling like a feminine man, these are the times I get to become a full-time drag queen! You never feel quite as fabulous as when you get to be a drag queen. I may identify as male, but love my body and take full advantage of having it. To be a man successfully tricking others to believe you are a woman is to be a successful trickster and to feel positively naughty. ![]()
When in my more “in-between” times is when I get the most looks from strangers, which is a thrill of its own. I love breaking the norm, making people think and question everything they’ve ever learned about gender and what it means to be a man or a woman. I want people to wonder, “he or she?”
When in the Summer between Junior and Senior year of high school I attended a sort of theatre camp. While they we had classes and workshops to improve our acting abilities. There would be over a hundred other people there that I had never met, so I decided to test my ability to make people question my gender. I presented as Androgynous. I wore a small amount of eyeliner and no other makeup, I wore men’s shirts and women’s pants, and I bound my chest. I noticed immediately upon arrival that I was getting second glances from complete strangers that continued for the entire time I was at this Theatre camp. I later told one of the friends I made there about my little experiment and was informed that many of the people there did in fact question what I was. I was ecstatic.
I’ve been trying to avoid a pun, but I suppose I should just do the fluid thing and go with the flow.